ZeroDelay Academy · Field guide

Are roofing estimates followed up—and do accepted jobs retain margin?

Estimate follow-up and job margin are two different questions. Measure whether a documented follow-up happened, then review the direct costs of won jobs without crediting follow-up for wins it may not have caused.

By ZeroDelay.ai · An educational framework, not a customer case study

A question to start with

Are estimates going quiet, or are accepted jobs costing more than the scope allowed?

  1. Step 1

    Audit the estimate handoff

    For estimates sent in one period, record send date, owner, next-contact date, customer response and outcome. Use a consistent follow-up window, such as seven days, as an internal audit rule—not an industry benchmark.

  2. Step 2

    Compare quoted and final scope

    For accepted jobs, track change orders and actual square footage, tear-off, decking and disposal. Keep tax and pass-through charges consistent across comparisons.

  3. Step 3

    Bridge direct job costs

    Subtract actual materials, crew labor, subcontractors, permits and disposal from collected job revenue. This contribution margin is not net profit; overhead and warranty reserves still matter.

Fictional worked example

All figures below are made-up assumptions to show the arithmetic. They are not industry averages, customer data, achieved outcomes or a forecast for your business.

Assumptions

  • Fictional set of 30 estimates sent in a month; 12 have a documented follow-up within seven days, and 6 are accepted. The six acceptances are not attributed to follow-up.
  • For a separate illustrative cost calculation, six completed jobs each collected $12,000 before tax.
  • Per completed job: $4,500 materials, $2,800 crew labor and $1,100 combined subcontractor, permit and disposal costs.
  • Office overhead, marketing, financing, warranty reserve and taxes are excluded.

Simple math

  1. Documented follow-up coverage: 12 ÷ 30 = 40%; 18 estimates have no follow-up recorded within seven days. Missing records do not prove no contact occurred.
  2. Illustrative direct cost per completed job: $4,500 + $2,800 + $1,100 = $8,400. Direct contribution: $12,000 − $8,400 = $3,600.
  3. Across six jobs: 6 × $12,000 = $72,000 revenue; 6 × $3,600 = $21,600 direct contribution. Contribution margin: $21,600 ÷ $72,000 = 30%, before overhead.
  4. Estimate vs actual: if each job was quoted assuming $8,000 of direct cost, the expected contribution was $12,000 − $8,000 = $4,000 (about 33.3%). The actual $8,400 cost leaves $400 less per job, or 6 × $400 = $2,400 across the six jobs. Better follow-up would not close that gap; it comes from cost or scope.

What this suggests checking: The follow-up audit identifies a documentation gap, not a causal sales opportunity. The margin calculation is a cost check, not a promised result. Look at actual job-level variance and customer responses before changing process or pricing.

Next checks using your own records

  • Review the 18 estimates with no recorded follow-up: was contact made elsewhere, was a next step agreed, or did the customer decline?
  • Compare estimated and actual material quantities, labor days and change-order approvals on completed jobs.
  • Allocate overhead and warranty reserves before calling the remaining contribution profit.

A worksheet you can repeat

  1. 1. Estimate follow-up ledger

    One row per estimate sent: date sent, owner, first follow-up date, agreed next step, outcome and outcome date. Keep the review window fixed so late outcomes do not rewrite the earlier audit.

  2. 2. Won-job cost ledger

    For each accepted and completed job: collected revenue before tax, estimated and actual materials, crew labor, subcontractors, permits and disposal, plus approved change orders. Calculate contribution from actuals.

  3. 3. Keep the two apart

    Follow-up coverage answers whether estimates were pursued. Won-job contribution answers whether accepted work kept its margin. A higher acceptance count can still lower total contribution if the extra jobs are priced below their actual cost.

A related next step: check roofing job handoff readiness before scheduling.

What the numbers cannot tell you

  • Follow-up records show activity, not cause; this example does not claim follow-up wins jobs.
  • Contribution margin excludes overhead, warranty reserves and taxes, so it is not net profit.
  • The figures are fictional and are not roofing industry benchmarks.

Want to use your own figures? Explore the free Service Business Profit Leak Check. Its calculations stay in your browser.

Want to see how a full plan ranks findings like these? View the fictional sample 90-Day Plan.

Share this guide

Nothing is posted automatically.